
I thought I’d do a review of garters and what better way to compare garters than with your most uncooperative pair of stockings? ;) I came up with the idea & shot it about a month ago, but there weren’t any garters to sell at that time. So my review waited, and now that there’s oodles of garters, these E.G. Smith heather over the knee stockings are all sold out. lol. Oh well. :) I’ll still share a bit about the EG’s…. They’re soft and flannel like, and have gargantuan stretch. They also don’t stay up for anything. Completely uncooperative. So they NEED garters.

On the left leg is Miss Dater’s Ladies Adjustable Garters and on the right leg is Sock-Dream’s garters with brass buttons that I bought last year. The Dater’s garters are of a thinner, more stretchy elastic and the middle of the clip part pops out like a front close bra clasp. As you can tell from the picture I have more thigh bulge happening with the Dater’s. This is because they were not holding up my stockings very well. I kept tightening them and they kept slipping, and eventually they were too tight, creating bulge and hurting my legs. And they still kept slipping, so I was not only pulling up the stockings, but the garters as well. :( Also, I don’t think our sock friends with sturdier legs will be able to wear these up on their thighs, but OTK or knee high height always looks cute, and you’ll want to show off the darling little retro clip anyway.
The Sock-Dream’s garters where completely different. The elastic is thick and sturdy enough that it doesn’t cut into my delicate Lady flesh. :) The garter stayed put and also held up my disgruntled stockings. The buttons are a bit of an effort to get thru the holes at first, especially if you have long fingernails. But with the new lowered prices on garters, I’ll be getting pairs for thigh high height as well as over the knee heights and won’t have to mess with doing the buttons but just the once.

The Miss Dater’s Ladies Adjustable Garters are good looking and fun for stockings that have some of their own stay up power, but if you’re wearing something that needs serious garter help, the Sock-Dreams garters were the clear winner for keeping up stockings that love to fall down.